Compostable sous vide bags: myth or reality? Environmental impact and composting in France in 2023

Compostable and biodegradable sous vide bags are increasingly promoted as an environmentally friendly alternative to conventional plastic bags. But what actually happens to them after use? Can they be placed in a home compost bin? Are industrial composting facilities equipped to process them? And, above all, is it worth paying two or three times more for a bag that may ultimately be incinerated?

At Sous Vide Consulting, we regularly receive questions about these new types of bags designed for vacuum food storage and sous vide cooking. A statement published by ANSES on 28 November 2022 particularly caught our attention. It prompted us to examine the environmental claims made about these products and share our assessment of the situation in France in 2023.

Our findings in France in 2023: a bag labelled biodegradable or compostable will not necessarily break down in a home compost bin. Furthermore, industrial waste treatment facilities are not always equipped or organised to process these materials. The word "compostable" therefore does not guarantee that a bag will actually be turned into compost.

Why Does ANSES Advise Against Compostable Bags in Home Compost?

ANSES (French Agency for Food, Environmental and Occupational Health & Safety) is a French public agency responsible for assessing health and environmental risks. Its recommendations therefore deserve serious consideration. According to ANSES, plastic materials, even those labelled "biodegradable" or "compostable", can become a source of pollution when placed in domestic or community composting systems.

The problem is straightforward: natural composting conditions do not always provide sufficient control over temperature, humidity and the decomposition process. Complete degradation of the bags cannot therefore be guaranteed, creating a risk of plastic residues entering the compost and subsequently contaminating soil and crops. ANSES consequently recommends keeping plastic materials out of home compost bins, even when they are certified as compostable.

ANSES advises against placing compostable and biodegradable plastic bags in home compost bins

Instead, ANSES recommends collection and treatment through suitable industrial waste management systems, as with other types of packaging. But are these facilities actually available for compostable sous vide bags in France? This is precisely the question we want to explore.

Biodegradable, Bio-Based or Compostable: What Is the Difference?

These three terms are often confused. A biodegradable material can be broken down by microorganisms under certain conditions. A compostable material meets specific biodegradation and disintegration requirements under defined composting conditions. Finally, a bio-based plastic is manufactured entirely or partly from renewable resources, such as corn starch, potato starch or sugar beet.

A bio-based plastic is therefore not necessarily compostable, and a compostable plastic is not necessarily plant-based. Some compostable materials may contain polymers derived from petrochemicals. In all cases, compostable does not mean that a material will biodegrade quickly in the natural environment.

Compostable Bags: Myth or Reality?

In 2019, researchers at the University of Plymouth in the United Kingdom investigated the behaviour of conventional, biodegradable and compostable plastic bags. The bags were exposed to outdoor air, buried in soil or submerged in seawater over several years.

The findings were particularly revealing: after three years, some bags marketed as biodegradable were still strong enough to carry groceries. The compostable bag tested degraded more quickly in seawater but was still present in soil after 27 months. Above all, the study demonstrated that environmental claims do not guarantee rapid degradation under all natural conditions.

These results do not mean that compostability standards are pointless. They simply remind us that a material designed to break down under specific conditions will not necessarily behave in the same way in a garden, river or ocean.

What Compostability Standards Applied in France in 2023?

Two main standards govern the compostability of plastics. They establish testing conditions and biodegradation criteria, but they do not guarantee that every bag will actually be composted after use.

Standard Composting Method Main Requirements
NF T51-800:2015 Home composting At least 90% biodegradation under specified test conditions, over a period of up to 12 months.
NF EN 13432:2000 Industrial composting of packaging At least 90% biodegradation under specified test conditions, over a period of up to 6 months.

Industrial composting generally makes it possible to maintain higher temperatures, around 55 to 60°C, while controlling humidity and regularly turning the material. These conditions encourage the breakdown of compostable plastics. By contrast, a home compost bin is exposed to changing temperatures and weather conditions.

However, an important question remains: what happens to any remaining residues and microplastics? In its November 2022 statement, ANSES highlighted limitations in existing assessment methods and called for stricter requirements. Compliance with a compostability standard does not mean that a bag will disappear completely in every environment.

Are Compostable Bags Actually Processed by Industrial Facilities?

This is where things become more complicated. In France in 2023, collection and treatment systems for compostable plastic bags remained limited. Some industrial composting and anaerobic digestion facilities refused these materials, even when they carried industrial compostability certification. The reasons were largely technical: processing cycles could be too short, plastic films could interfere with machinery, and the materials might not break down sufficiently before the end of the treatment process.

An article published by the French industry magazine L'Usine Nouvelle in 2020 illustrates this paradox: a bag may comply with a compostability standard without being accepted by an industrial facility. Anaerobic digestion plants, in particular, are not necessarily designed to process compostable plastics.

Collection and industrial processing challenges for compostable plastic bags in France in 2023

In practice, when suitable treatment facilities are unavailable, many compostable bags may end up in residual household waste and be incinerated rather than converted into compost. Although some local initiatives exist, they do not provide a widespread solution for compostable vacuum storage or sous vide cooking bags in France.

A Technical, Economic or Political Problem?

It is reasonable to question the reasons behind this situation. Is it a lack of political commitment, the influence of conventional plastics industries or economic difficulties? Several factors may be involved. However, the technical constraints faced by industrial facilities should not be underestimated: processing times, material separation, equipment operation and the quality of the finished compost.

Furthermore, some scientific studies have raised questions about the safety of certain bio-based or biodegradable materials. A scientific study published in 2020 investigated the potential toxicity of certain bioplastic products. These findings encourage caution, but they do not establish that all compostable bags present the same risks.

Should You Buy Compostable Sous Vide Bags in 2023?

We are all concerned about the environmental impact of single-use plastics. Researchers and manufacturers are developing new materials, and we naturally hope that their work will lead to satisfactory solutions. However, when it comes to compostable vacuum storage and sous vide cooking bags available in 2023, we remain cautious, particularly in view of the situation in France.

Why pay two or three times more for a bag marketed as environmentally friendly if it ultimately enters the same waste disposal system as a conventional plastic bag? Without a practical composting solution, the claimed environmental benefit becomes difficult to justify. It is also essential to ensure that the bag is suitable for food contact and, when intended for sous vide cooking, for the required cooking temperatures and durations.

Our assessment in France in 2023: we do not recommend purchasing compostable vacuum storage or sous vide cooking bags solely on the basis of their environmental claims, particularly when they cost significantly more than conventional bags. An exception may be justified when a specialised waste treatment facility actually accepts these bags and guarantees that they will be processed under suitable conditions.

This does not mean that we oppose research into bioplastics or wish to discourage environmental initiatives. At Sous Vide Consulting, however, we do not want to offer our customers products whose advertised benefits we cannot verify. Without automatically labelling these claims as greenwashing, we believe it is important to distinguish marketing promises from actual waste treatment possibilities.

Frequently Asked Questions About Compostable Sous Vide Bags

 

Can compostable bags be placed in a home compost bin?

ANSES advised against this practice in November 2022. Even when a bag is labelled compostable, complete degradation cannot be guaranteed under real home composting conditions.

What is the difference between biodegradable and compostable bags?

A biodegradable bag can be broken down by microorganisms under certain conditions. A compostable bag must meet specific composting requirements. Neither should be assumed to disappear quickly in the natural environment.

Are compostable bags accepted by industrial composting facilities?

Not always. In France in 2023, many facilities were not equipped or organised to process these materials. Some bags could therefore be rejected and sent for incineration instead of composting. Waste treatment practices may differ in other countries.

Are compostable vacuum bags suitable for sous vide cooking?

Compostability does not guarantee suitability for sous vide cooking. The manufacturer must explicitly confirm that the bag is approved for food contact and for the intended cooking temperatures and durations.

Are compostable sous vide bags really environmentally friendly?

Their environmental benefits depend on how they are manufactured, used and, above all, treated after disposal. In France in 2023, the limited availability of suitable industrial composting facilities made it difficult to justify a substantial price premium.

Conclusion: Looking Ahead

Despite these somewhat discouraging findings, we should not give up. Materials are evolving, and waste treatment systems may gradually adapt. We will therefore continue to follow innovations in vacuum storage and sous vide cooking bags, along with research into their environmental impact.

In the meantime, we prefer to focus on proven solutions, transparent information and products suited to the real needs of food professionals. We also plan to dedicate a future article to recyclable vacuum storage and sous vide cooking bags, another avenue worth exploring.

For more information about different types of vacuum bags and their applications, please visit our guide to vacuum sealers and sous vide cooking bags.

The Sous Vide Consulting Team